Tuesday, 7 April 2009

Must read: Interesting Pixar article in NY Times


Pixar’s Art Leaves Profit Watchers Edgy



LOS ANGELES — Pixar Animation Studios has never released a movie that was not a commercial and creative triumph, and its 10th feature, “Up,” is looking to be no exception — at least artistically.
To the extreme irritation of the Walt Disney Company, however, two important business camps — Wall Street and toy retailers — are notably down on “Up.”
The film, about the adventures of a cranky 78-year-old who ties thousands of balloons to his house, features dazzling animation that evokes the work of Hayao Miyazaki, the refined Japanese filmmaker and anime master. Like Pixar’s Oscar-winning “Wall-E,” there are stretches without dialogue. A few scenes are rendered in black and white.

Some industry watchers, a few of them still griping about the hefty $7.4 billion that Disney paid for Pixar in 2006, are fretting about the film’s commercial potential, particularly when it comes to benefiting other Disney businesses.
Richard Greenfield of Pali Research downgraded Disney shares to sell last month, citing a poor outlook for “Up” as a reason. “We doubt younger boys will be that excited by the main character,” he wrote, adding a complaint about the lack of a female lead.
Mr. Greenfield is alone in his vociferousness, but not in his opinion.

“People seem to be concerned about this one,” said Chris Marangi, who follows Disney at Gabelli & Company. Doug Creutz of Cowen and Company said qualms ran deeper than whether “Up” will be a hit — he thinks it will — but rather whether Pixar can deliver the kind of megahit it once did.
“The worries keep coming despite Pixar’s track record, because each film it delivers seems to be less commercial than the last,” Mr. Creutz said.
Robert A. Iger, Disney’s chief executive, responded, “We seek to make great films first. If a great film gives birth to a franchise, we are the first company to leverage such success. A check-the-boxes approach to creativity is more likely to result in blandness and failure.”
The budget for “Up” is about $175 million excluding marketing, on par with other Pixar titles. “Up” will not arrive in theaters until May 29, but Pixarphiles — nudged along by the studio, which has been screening footage — are already effusive.

“Sophisticated, mature, poignant,” wrote Blue Sky Disney, a blog that chronicles everything Pixar. The Cannes Film Festival is so excited about “Up,” which will be released in 3-D, that it slotted the film on its prestigious opening night, a huge promotional platform that has never before gone to an animated film or a 3-D one.
Adjusted for inflation, Pixar’s films have generated a combined $2.65 billion at North American theaters, a spectacular showing. “Finding Nemo” in 2003 was the high point, selling $405.6 million in tickets.
Pixar’s last two films, “Wall-E” and “Ratatouille,” have been the studio’s two worst performers, delivering sales of $224 million and $216 million respectively, according to Box Office Mojo, a tracking service. Attendance for Pixar films has also dropped sharply over the years, suggesting that ticket price inflation helped prop up overall sales for “Wall-E” and “Ratatouille.”

Retailers, meanwhile, see slim merchandising possibilities for “Up.” Indeed, the film seems likely to generate less licensing revenue than “Ratatouille,” until now the weakest Pixar entry in this area. (“Cars” wears the merchandising crown, with sales of more than $5 billion.)
Target and Wal-Mart say they will stock little “Up” merchandise, mainly because there was not much interest from manufacturers: Thinkway Toys, which has churned out thousands of Pixar-related products since 1995’s “Toy Story,” will not produce a single item. Disney Stores will offer “Up”-related products, but even that will be on a limited basis, according to analysts.
Disney sees the worry as unfair and tiresome given Pixar’s track record.
With “Ratatouille,” analysts fretted about whether moviegoers would go to see a movie about a rat in the kitchen. They did. With “Wall-E,” people feared the lack of dialogue would bore children. It did not.
So, Disney says, hasn’t Pixar earned the benefit of the doubt?

“Once again, trying to go after a premise that is far-fetched,” a written response from Disney read in part. The company noted that there is a child character in the film — a portly 8-year-old who stows away on the septuagenarian’s porch — and pointed to positive comments on blogs like Pixar Planet and Cinema Is Dope, which called the movie “entertainingly buoyant.”
Disney marketers had hoped to curtail the it’s-not-commercial reaction to “Up” by breaking with past practice and widely screening unfinished footage of the film. Inside the studio, executives are bullish on it, particularly because focus groups have responded favorably. The company added that it does not expect every Pixar movie to become a franchise.

After “Up,” the overtly commercial “Toy Story 3” arrives in 2010 and “Cars 2” in 2011, and there is much talk that a sequel to “Monsters Inc.” is in the works.
Perhaps Wall Street would not care so much if Pixar seemed to care a little more. The co-director of “Up,” Pete Docter — who also directed “Monsters Inc.” — said in a recent question and answer session with reporters that the film’s commercial prospects never crossed his mind. “We make these films for ourselves,” he said. “We’re kind of selfish that way.”
John Lasseter, a co-founder of Pixar and now Disney’s chief creative officer, routinely says in interviews that marketability is not a factor in decisions about what projects to pursue. Instead of ideas that feel contemporary, he aims for stories that are rooted in the ages.
“Quality is the best business plan” is one of Mr. Lasseter’s favorite lines.

A commercial juggernaut or not, “Up” has struck many early viewers as creatively stunning. The story focuses on Carl (voiced by Ed Asner), a prune-popping balloon salesman who, after the death of his wife, sets out to see the wilds of South America.
His young companion, Russell (voiced by Jordan Nagai), is a “Wilderness Explorer” working on his last merit badge, “assisting the elderly.” An exotic bird joins the excursion, which encounters a hilarious squad of talking dogs.
The animation is heavily stylized. Carl is not realistic looking, for instance, but has square features: fingertips, face, liver spots. The color palette is notable for its turquoise and magenta.

Nothing involving the picture was rushed — Pixar spent four years on it — and, apparently, no expense was spared. Mr. Docter and some of his colleagues flew to Venezuela for a three-day helicopter and Jeep tour to study jungle scenery; others spent time observing a rare pheasant at the Sacramento Zoo.
“We wanted more ‘Dumbo’ and less ‘Star Wars,’ ” Mr. Docter said. “In certain parts, it’s more of a feeling we’re going after than linear storytelling.”

Wednesday, 1 April 2009

Latest screening: Monsters Vs Aliens (oh boy!)


I find it hard to fathom why the critics have been so kind to this dull wasted opportunity. The trades were positive; it has a 70% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. My only thought – 3D has blinded people again.

I hope people start waking up to poor films rendered in beautiful dynamic technology like this and Beowulf soon. This reminds me of computer animation. With the redoubtable Pixar leading the way everyone thought computer animation was the second coming, that it could do no wrong. And quickly those jumping on the bandwagon ignored the noble Pixar aims of getting the absolute best story, voices, artists etc together to create a truly great movie and we were inundated with bilge like Shrek 2, Shark Tale, Robots, Valiant and Madagascar, until – thank the good lord – the proliferation of utter crap in 2006 (Ant Bully, The Wild, Flushed Away, Open Season) made audiences notice the films themselves still needed to be good regardless of how they were rendered. Of course the backlash also hit some quite good films, Pixar’s weak-for-them but underrated Cars and Sony’s surprisingly good Monster House, but that was inevitable.

The film industry has always been prone to sweeping statements and DreamWorks Animation is the worst purveyor of this. Jeffrey Katzenberg and his team of soulless money-grubbers thought they could match Pixar’s majesty by churning out pop-culture referencing rubbish again and again. For every good DWA film (arguably only Antz, Shrek and Kung Fu Panda – and maybe at a stretch Bee Movie – fit this) there are two painfully awful ones. For every bad Pixar film there are, well… there are no bad Pixar films! Even the worst (Cars, A Bug’s Life) are better than almost anything DWA has done (again here I’d say Shrek and Kung Fu Panda are better to be fair).

For crying out loud DWA even managed to make Aardman look bad with a weak Curse Of The Were-Rabbit and the downright appallingly unfunny Flushed Away. DWA kissed off traditional animation, with Katzenberg saying in 2003 “"I think the idea of a traditional story being told using traditional animation is likely a thing of the past." Meanwhile Pixar’s John Lasseter brought the extraordinary films of Japan’s Hayao Miyazaki to broader Western attention.

Now it seems to me that 3D is the new blinding science! It does look great. I’m the first to admit that. Hell I wrote a big feature for a trade magazine, interviewing James Cameron about it in summer 2006. I’ve seen 3D test footage of Titanic, Star Wars: Episode IV and Lord Of The Rings. I’ve seen more than 10 films in the new 3D. And yes even on crap like Journey To The Center Of The Earth it does add an element of entertainment. But positive reviews for films like Beowulf and Monsters Vs Aliens make me feel critics are reviewing the technology not the film. Indeed, when Beowulf came out nearly every positive review waxed lyrical about how amazing the 3D was while either ignoring the film or, occasionally, having to admit the film behind the effect was pretty poor.

I think 3D has to seen as a tool to add to a great movie, not as a way to excuse bad ones. Three of my most anticipated films of the year (see post Jan 19 this year) are 3D – James Cameron’s Avatar, Henry Selick’s Coraline and Pixar’s Up – but I believe all the filmmakers involved will deliver a great film first and a great 3D event second. For me Monsters Vs Aliens seems lazy and the emphasis Jeffrey Katzenberg puts on 3D is disturbingly like saying “if you build it they will come”. I love Field Of Dreams as much as the next sap but damn if those ghostly baseball players didn’t put on a good game it’d be a disappointment, right?

Monsters Vs Aliens is just that: a huge disappointment. The “message” is hackneyed and unsubtle. The jokes are over-played and stepped on again and again. In typical DWA style a funny joke is grasped like life-preserver and repeated over-and-over or expanded upon unnecessarily to kill the laugh so dead you can’t figure out what element started out seeming funny. I love ’50s B-movies and the character designs of the monsters (Fly-esque Dr Cockroach, Creature From The Black Lagoon-esque Missing Link, funny Blob B.O.B., Mothra-like Insectosaurus and 50 Foot Woman Ginormica) are well done and the voices chosen fit them well for once (none of that Shark Tale “cram another misjudged celeb voice in” here), but that makes it all the more inexcusable that the film struggles to raise a film or a whoop!

Good concept, good design, good voice casting should help achieve a good film, right? Of course, but as with everything the script must come first and as is typical of DWA it seems as if that element was an afterthought. The set-pieces are uninspired. The most adorable character (Insectosaurus) is wasted and then ruined! Critics have said this is Seth Rogen’s (B.O.B.) film and what laughs there are do come from his character but they are all (and I mean ALL) in the trailers.

It is such a shame that what could easily have been a great film was so hugely screwed up because the people behind it were fixated on the technology when they should have been paying attention elsewhere. DWA delivered one of its best films last year with a well voice-cast, smart, funny, genre-spinning animation – Kung Fu Panda. That was the promise Monsters Vs Aliens had, but they delivered an uninspired Over The Hedge-a-like!

On the plus side it was better than last year’s computer-animated low, Igor!

Friday, 27 March 2009

New Trailer: Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs

Not loving the look of this one but it has to be said that while Pixar and DreamWorks Animation have continued to grab the kudos (Pixar), limelight and box office Sony Pictures Animation have quietly been making some of the most interesting (at least non-Pixar) computer-animated movies of recent years.

Monster House was, and remains, one of the few 3D movies that was actually good enough to watch regardless of the 3D, while the following year's Surf's Up was a surprisingly clever kids film, smartly done. Unfortunately for Monster House it came in the over-saturated summer of 2006 when the shine of CG animation was fading and a lot of movies were getting dismissed. It didn't help that Sony decided to release late summer instead of the more obvious Halloween run up. Surf's Up suffered from starring penguin characters 6 months after Happy Feet. Surf's Up wiped the floor with Happy Feet but few bothered to find out.

This one isn't really appealing to me from the trailer (link below and in the trailer bar on the right) but i missed Surf's Up in the cinema because i pre-judged and regretted it so i will watch this one.

http://www.cloudywithachanceofmeatballs.com/

Thursday, 26 March 2009

Latest screening: The Burning Plain


Not scheduled to open until September in the US, The Burning Plain is a frustrating film, that you can't quite decide if it is successful or not.
I must warn here that i will be discussing plot points which while i don't think they spoil the enjoyment of the film would be construed as spoilers.
The directorial debut of Babel/Amores Perros/21 Grams/Three Burials writer Guillermo Arriaga, it is unsurprisingly a tale of interwoven stories. The curious thing about this film is as a film with "twists and turns" it is wholly unsuccessful - you see each and every one coming down the road for miles! - but it seems that to Arriaga that is fine.
As a piece of drama i have to admit i liked it. It is slight but as a study of emotion and family dynamics, of forbidden relationships (forbidden by both external and internal forces) and of regret and emotional burden it is fascinating. Yes it is languid. Much of the criticism i have heard levelled at it is that little of interest happens but i don't agree, i enjoy the snapshot of the lives we get here.
I suspect the issues with it really lie with the idea that the twists aren't interesting, and that is because they are delivered in a lazy way that suggests Arriaga knows they are obvious so why bother. I can't help thinking this intentional. After all the film would like to suggest it is a surprise for us to find Theron's character is the adult version of Basinger's daughter - but every description i have seen of the film mentions Basinger is Theron's mother in the movie. I have to say going into it with only the knowledge of the IMDb plot outline in my head it surprised me more to find they didn't share scenes and as a viewer i wasn't meant to know. That said even had i not known it seemed blatantly obvious. As did the fact that the Latino girl was Theron's abandoned daughter. Again, this was clearer meant to be a revelation but the part was so well cast that from the first glimpse of the girl i thought "she bares a weird likeness to Theron, she must be her daughter" and sure enough...! Indeed, every so-called revelation in the movie was blindingly obvious.
I therefore have to conclude that if the viewer is meant to be carried from revelation to revelation finding surprise at every turn then this film is spectacularly badly done. Honestly, i apologise if you feel i've spoilt the film but within 20-25 minutes of the start you will have figured out every possible "surprise" this film has to offer.
That said seen as having no intention of surprising but purely as a character study i did enjoy its slow paced telling. All the performances were strong with Theron and Basinger as good as they have ever been and 18-year-old Jennifer Lawrence a revelation - she's definitely one to watch. I certainly liked the film as much as Babel or 21 Grams.

Wednesday, 18 March 2009

Best promo images for a poor film ever!


Perhaps even just best promo images ever. These are for Sky's screenings of Alien Vs Predator and its sequel - genius (the images not the films, although i must shamefully admit to having a soft spot for the so-bad-its-good sequel, the first was just crap!)

I honestly can't decide which one i like best. I'm leaning towards the pool one but the chess in the library is very cool and there's something just plain brilliant about the swingball one. If only so much genius had gone into the films!



Friday, 13 March 2009

New trailer: latest Up

Ooh, finally a trailer for Pixar's Up that not only shows us something about the actual story and characters but manages to work for me. The teasers did nothing for me at all - the for first time since Cars.

This trailer looks funny, perhaps funnier than any Pixar since Monsters, Inc - although I personally found WALL-E, Ratatouille and The Incredibles very funny.

Yet another flawless offering from Pixar? Looks like it. Love the "talking" dog idea!

http://www.traileraddict.com/trailer/up/trailer-b

Thursday, 12 March 2009

Highly recommended viewing: Oliver Stone

The link below is to a fascinating talk recorded at University of Southern California on March 3 with Oliver Stone.

It covers the Vietnam trilogy, Wall Street, Natural Born Killers, JFK, Nixon, W. and much more of his work but is more than a look at Stone, it is an intellectual discussion of the role of media in todays society, the rise of image and spin over fact and many others things - think a Sight & Sound article version of a talk! It is fascinating listening for anyone really interested in film and interesting filmmakers.

I find Stone fascinating. Many people dismiss him out of turn. Many completely buy into his rhetoric. I find neither path wise. I have seen him speak in person on more than one occasion and i find him intelligent, witty, charming and passionate, but also at times prone to over-statement. He says in this talk that Hollywood studios spend three times the production budget on marketing. The point he is making is Hollywood values what it can market - the product - over the quality of the film - the art. It is a valid point. But the statement he makes is a gross exaggeration and it is things like this that get him into trouble; that his detractors leap upon time and again.

Never-the-less i always find his work worthy of attention. No matter the outcome of his last film i will always anticipate a new one, he is that type of filmmaker - never dull, always challenging. He is like Brian De Palma or Paul Schrader in that way. All three are filmmakers who i find myself disliking probably about the same amount of their work as i like but Alexander did not lessen my interest in World Trade Center and that film did not alter my interest in seeing W. I thought The Black Dahlia was awful (and Femme Fatale - which went straight to video here in the UK - before it was as bad if not worse) but that did not stop me seeing Redacted in the cinema. I found Schrader's The Walker fairly dull but a new Schrader film is cause to suit up and head down the arthouse and i look forward (should it see UK release) to catching Adam Resurrected when i can.

The below link is accessed through Deadline Hollywood. I didn't time the whole thing because i was listening to it while working but it is about an hour i think, so best to do what i did and listen while doing other things. I recommend it though.

http://www.deadlinehollywooddaily.com/oliver-stone-on-wall-street-then-now/