
To the extreme irritation of the Walt Disney Company, however, two important business camps — Wall Street and toy retailers — are notably down on “Up.”
The film, about the adventures of a cranky 78-year-old who ties thousands of balloons to his house, features dazzling animation that evokes the work of Hayao Miyazaki, the refined Japanese filmmaker and anime master. Like Pixar’s Oscar-winning “Wall-E,” there are stretches without dialogue. A few scenes are rendered in black and white.
Some industry watchers, a few of them still griping about the hefty $7.4 billion that Disney paid for Pixar in 2006, are fretting about the film’s commercial potential, particularly when it comes to benefiting other Disney businesses.
Mr. Greenfield is alone in his vociferousness, but not in his opinion.
“People seem to be concerned about this one,” said Chris Marangi, who follows Disney at Gabelli & Company. Doug Creutz of Cowen and Company said qualms ran deeper than whether “Up” will be a hit — he thinks it will — but rather whether Pixar can deliver the kind of megahit it once did.
The budget for “Up” is about $175 million excluding marketing, on par with other Pixar titles. “Up” will not arrive in theaters until May 29, but Pixarphiles — nudged along by the studio, which has been screening footage — are already effusive.
“Sophisticated, mature, poignant,” wrote Blue Sky Disney, a blog that chronicles everything Pixar. The Cannes Film Festival is so excited about “Up,” which will be released in 3-D, that it slotted the film on its prestigious opening night, a huge promotional platform that has never before gone to an animated film or a 3-D one.
Adjusted for inflation, Pixar’s films have generated a combined $2.65 billion at North American theaters, a spectacular showing. “Finding Nemo” in 2003 was the high point, selling $405.6 million in tickets.
Retailers, meanwhile, see slim merchandising possibilities for “Up.” Indeed, the film seems likely to generate less licensing revenue than “Ratatouille,” until now the weakest Pixar entry in this area. (“Cars” wears the merchandising crown, with sales of more than $5 billion.)
Disney sees the worry as unfair and tiresome given Pixar’s track record.
With “Ratatouille,” analysts fretted about whether moviegoers would go to see a movie about a rat in the kitchen. They did. With “Wall-E,” people feared the lack of dialogue would bore children. It did not.
“Once again, trying to go after a premise that is far-fetched,” a written response from Disney read in part. The company noted that there is a child character in the film — a portly 8-year-old who stows away on the septuagenarian’s porch — and pointed to positive comments on blogs like Pixar Planet and Cinema Is Dope, which called the movie “entertainingly buoyant.”
Disney marketers had hoped to curtail the it’s-not-commercial reaction to “Up” by breaking with past practice and widely screening unfinished footage of the film. Inside the studio, executives are bullish on it, particularly because focus groups have responded favorably. The company added that it does not expect every Pixar movie to become a franchise.
After “Up,” the overtly commercial “Toy Story 3” arrives in 2010 and “Cars 2” in 2011, and there is much talk that a sequel to “Monsters Inc.” is in the works.
“Quality is the best business plan” is one of Mr. Lasseter’s favorite lines.
A commercial juggernaut or not, “Up” has struck many early viewers as creatively stunning. The story focuses on Carl (voiced by Ed Asner), a prune-popping balloon salesman who, after the death of his wife, sets out to see the wilds of South America.
Nothing involving the picture was rushed — Pixar spent four years on it — and, apparently, no expense was spared. Mr. Docter and some of his colleagues flew to Venezuela for a three-day helicopter and Jeep tour to study jungle scenery; others spent time observing a rare pheasant at the Sacramento Zoo.




I honestly can't decide which one i like best. I'm leaning towards the pool one but the chess in the library is very cool and there's something just plain brilliant about the swingball one. If only so much genius had gone into the films!